Tax Comparison: Spring valley, NY vs Butler, PA
Understanding Your Tax Burden
This page compares the three main types of taxes between Spring valley, NY and Butler, PA: property tax, income tax, and sales tax. Each of these has a different impact on your overall cost of living.
Property Tax Comparison
Property taxes are collected by local governments and used to fund schools, infrastructure, and other local services. They're typically based on the assessed value of your property.
Our property tax estimates are based on:
- U.S. median home value: $419,200 (2023 data)
- Local effective tax rates for both cities
Spring valley, NY
$7,431
Based on a $419,200 home
Rate: 1.7726%
Butler, PA
$4,487
Based on a $419,200 home
Rate: 1.0704%
| Data | Spring valley, NY | Butler, PA |
|---|---|---|
| Effective Property Tax Rate | 1.7726% | 1.0704% |
| Estimated Property Tax | $7,431 | $4,487 |
| Home Value Used | $419,200 | $419,200 |
Comparison: Property taxes in Butler, PA are $2,944 lower than in Spring valley, NY for the same home value.
State Income Tax Comparison
Income tax rates and brackets vary by state, impacting residents' overall tax burden. The estimates below are based on standard deductions and typical filing scenarios.
Our income tax estimates consider:
- Single filer: $100,000 annual income
- Married couple: $200,000 combined income
- Median income: $80,600 annual income
NY
4%-10.9%
Single: $5,436
Married: $9,785
PA
3.07%
Single: $3,070
Married: $5,526
| Data | NY | PA |
|---|---|---|
| Tax Rate | 4%-10.9% | 3.07% |
| Single Filer ($100k) | $5,436 | $3,070 |
| Married Couple ($200k) | $9,785 | $5,526 |
| Median Income ($80.6k) | $4,837 | $2,474 |
Comparison: Income taxes in PA are $2,363 lower than in NY for the median household income.
Sales Tax Comparison
Sales tax rates vary by location and can have a significant impact on your day-to-day expenses. These include state, county, city, and special district taxes that together form the total sales tax rate.
Our sales tax estimates consider:
- Average household taxable spending: $15,500 per year
- Combined state and local rates for both cities
Spring valley, NY
8.875%
Combined rate
Annual sales tax: $1375
(Based on $15,500 spending)
Butler, PA
8.000%
Combined rate
Annual sales tax: $1240
(Based on $15,500 spending)
| Data | Spring valley, NY | Butler, PA |
|---|---|---|
| State Sales Tax | 4.00% | 6.00% |
| Combined Sales Tax | 8.875% | 8.000% |
| Annual Tax Amount | $1,375 | $1,240 |
Comparison: Shopping in Butler, PA costs $135 less in annual sales tax than in Spring valley, NY for the average household.
Tax Comparison Insights
Tax Insights: Spring valley vs Butler
- Property Tax: Butler has a 0.7022 percentage points lower effective property tax rate than Spring valley.
- Income Tax: Living in PA could save you approximately $2,363 in state income taxes for a median household income.
- Sales Tax: The combined sales tax rate in Butler is 0.88 percentage points lower than in Spring valley.
Overall Tax Burden Comparison
Spring valley, NY
$13,642
Combined annual tax burden
Property
$7,431
Income
$4,837
Sales
$1,375
Butler, PA
$8,201
Combined annual tax burden
Property
$4,487
Income
$2,474
Sales
$1,240
Overall Comparison: Butler, PA has an estimated $5,441 lower total tax burden than Spring valley, NY based on our standard scenarios.
Important Tax Disclaimer
The tax information provided above is based on publicly available data and standard assumptions. Actual tax situations will vary based on:
- Individual financial circumstances
- Applicable deductions and credits
- Recent changes in tax laws
- Personal spending habits
- Local variations within cities and counties
This comparison is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be considered tax advice. For specific guidance regarding your tax situation, please consult with a qualified tax professional.